Home > Engineering essays > Increasing The Productivity By Reducing The Scrap And Rework Using Lean Manufacturing

Essay: Increasing The Productivity By Reducing The Scrap And Rework Using Lean Manufacturing

Essay details and download:

  • Subject area(s): Engineering essays
  • Reading time: 17 minutes
  • Price: Free download
  • Published: 15 September 2019*
  • Last Modified: 22 July 2024
  • File format: Text
  • Words: 4,873 (approx)
  • Number of pages: 20 (approx)

Text preview of this essay:

This page of the essay has 4,873 words.

1.0 Introduction:

1.1 History

The origin of Ashok Leyland can be traced to the urge for self-reliance, felt by' independent India. Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, India's prime minister persuaded Mr. Raghunandan saran, an industrialist, to enter auton10tive manufacturing.

In 1948, Ashok motors were set up in Chennai, for the assembly of Austin cars. The company's destiny and nature changed soon with equity participation by British Leyland and Ashok Leyland commenced Manufacture of commercial vehicles in 1955. Since then Ashok Leyland has been a major presence in India's commercial vehicle industry with a tradition of technological leadership, achieved through tie-ups with international technology leaders and through vigorous in-house R&D. Responding to the operating conditions and practices in the company, the company made its vehicles strong, over-engineering them with extra metallic muscles. "Designing durable products that make economic sense to the customer, using appropriate technology", became the design philosophy of the company, which in turn has molded consumer attitudes and the brand personality. The 5, 00,000 vehicles we have put on the roads have considerably eased the additional pressure place on road transportation in independent India.

In the populous Indian metro's, four out of the five State Transport Undertaking (STU) buses come from Ashok Leyland. Some of them like the double-decker and vestibule buses are unique models from Ashok Leyland, tailor made for high-density routes in 1987; the overseas holding by Land Rover Leyland International Holdings Limited (LRLIH) was taken over by a joint venture between the Hindu Group, the Non-Resident Indian tradition group and IVECO.

1.2 About Manufacturing Plant

At Hosur, there are three manufacturing units Plant-I located at 35 km from Bangalore on the area of 41.5 hectares (102 acres) and Plant-Il 15 km further away on the National Highway on an area of 121 hectares. In this plant, referred as Hosur Plant-I, facilities have been created for production of special vehicles and engines meeting specific customer requirements apart from regular models of commercial vehicles and engines while corporate engineering and quality control headquarters are located at Chennai (Ennore), local engineering and quality control departments to support these functions are available at Hosur.

The products of the company are well received in the market and they have a reputation for durability and high reliability. The engines produced in the plant are for industrials, marine and other application besides automotive application. The engines manufactured in the plant are being exposed to a number of countries.

The customers for the product of Ashok Leyland, Hosur include large goods and passenger fleet operators including state transport undertaking, individual truck/bus operators, and defense mining and other users in the country. This plant has been certified for ISO 14001 in the year 2014 and ISO/TS 16949 in the year 2016

1.3 Vision

  • Aligning all activities towards our vision “To be in the Global Top ten in M&HCV trucks (>7.5 T GVW) & Global Top 5 in M&HCV buses (8m&above) in volume terms”

  • Continually improving our products and processes to deliver superior value to all stakeholders.

    1.4 Environment Policy

    Ashok Leyland is committed to protecting the environment and will.

  • Fulfill the organization’s compliance obligations.

  • Adopt pollution prevention/reduction techniques in design, manufacture of its products and promote end of life disposal considering lifecycle perspective.

  • Conserve all resources such as power, water, oil, gas, compressed air etc., and maximize use of eco-friendly resources for our future design and manufacturing activities.

  • Continuously strive to minimize waste generation by all possible ways and reduce, reuse and recycle the same through a time bound action plan.

  • Provide a clean, safe and healthy work environment by spreading awareness and training.

  • Set and implement objectives and targets for continually addressing the environment impacts.

    Towards fulfilling the objectives, we prorogate our   environmental policy and our commitment to climate change mitigation, to all our stakeholders’ viz., employees, suppliers, customers and our neighbors. We will also strive towards enhancing our environmental sustainability.

    1.5 Gemba

    Cost and Gemba in Japanese means the place where all activities are actually taking place; in other words, the place where value is added. In case of the manufacturing industry, Gemba is the shop floor; for the hotel industry, it is the place where food is actually cooked; and in case of the service industry, it is everywhere. Gemba is thus the most precious place for the management. An empowered Gemba team, armed with skills and information takes full responsibilities for quality and delivery.

    1.6 Nine Initiatives

  • 5s

  • Agility

  • CMI

  • Critical machine

  • EEI

  • Go green

  • Inventory

  • Quality

  • Safety

    1.7 Layout

    1.8 Inhouse Facilities

    The Ashok Leyland, Hosur Unit-I is spread over approximately hundred acres having 3 machine shops, 2 Engine assembly shops, sophisticated Engine R&D centers. In one engine assembly shop Hino engines are assembled. In the second shop 680 and other AL models of engines are assembled which are used for industrial purpose, marine applications, and special applications.

    1.9 The Functions of Machine Shops

    Shop 1 – H-series head and block and P-15 head and block Machining ZD30 assembly, metrology.

    Shop 2 – H-series and P-15 engine assembly, testing and lacquering.

    Shop 3 – Heat Treatment/Tool Room Maintenance

    Shop 4 – H series block, camshaft, gears.

    Shop 5 – Heat Treatment  

    Shop 6 – Engine Stores

    Shop 7 – Logistics

    2.MACHINE SHOP I

    2.1 H-SERIES CYLINDER BLOCK

    It is a single casting, which acts as the base of the engine above which cylinder head is placed. Cylinder block forms the basic framework of the engine. It provides a rigid framework for various parts of the engine. It provides a block house for the combustion bores. Block house forms a part of lubrication system. It supports the lubrication oil passage. it has six faces.

    2.1.1 SPECIFICATIONS

  • Material – Grey cast iron

  • Hardness – 180-230 HB

  • Weight – 155Kg

  • Suppliers – M/s Ennore Foundries

  • M/s Hinduja Foundries

    2.1.2 HEAD FACE

  • Mounting of the cylinder head

  • Locking bolts

  • Piston assembly

    2.1.3 SUMP FACE

  • Assembly of sump

  • Dowel holes

  • Holes for mounting bearing caps

  • Holes for mounting oil pump passage

    2.1.4 LH FACE

  • Holes for dipstick

  • Oil seals and welch holes

    2.1.5 RH FACE

  • Oil coolers

  • Welch plugs

  • Oil filter

    2.1.6 Front Face

  • Idler gear

  • Idler gear shaft

  • Assembly of oil pump

  • Camshaft bore diameter, welch holes and dowel holes

    2.1.7 REAR FACE

  • Mounting of the flywheel

  • Welch plugs

    2.2 H-SERIES CYLINDER BLOCK LAYOUT

    2.3 H-SERIES CYLINDER BLOCK PLATFORM

    Sl.

    NO LA

    NO OP MIC DESCRIPTIO LINE BAY

    I 9653 010 MILL & DRILL LML*M446 HCB 1B

    2 4078 020 MILLING 2SP LML*M189 HCB 1B

    3 4013 030 MILLING SPL VER NOTCH LML *M183 HCB 1B

    4 9814 040 DUPLEX MILLING LML*LM457 HCB 1B

    5 4128 050 BORING ROUGH XLO*650337 HCB 1B

    6 4049 060 DRILL 2 WAY MULTI SP

    XLO*650324 HCB 1B

    7 8641 070 SPM MILLING BFW*8038020/97255 HCB 1B

    8 '4109 080 HB 800 PAL HCB 1B

    9 11402 090 LML SPM LM 662 HCB 1B

    10 8642 IOO SPM MILLING BFW I-ICB 1B

    11 4033 110 5 SP LINEAR INDEX TICO*M136 HCB 1B

    12 10131 120 BFW HM
    C HCB 1B

    13 4269 130 DRILL CNTR TICO TH25*Ml 71 HCB 1B

    14 9880 140 CNC MULTI DRILLING

    &REAMING HCB 1B

    15 8405 150 MULTI TAPPING HCB 1B

    16 8551 160 SPM 2 STN DRILLING TCO*M242 HCB 2B

    17 8547 170 SPM 2 STN TAPPING TCO*M243 HCB 2B

    18 4268 180 DRILL CNTR TICO TH25*M 170 HCB 2B

    19 8710 190 SPM 8STN DRILLING LML*LM356 HCB 2B

    20 4055 210 DRILL 5 SPM HORZ LML*M186 HCB 2B

    21 4058 220 DRILL 3 SPINDLE TICO*M142 HCB 2B

    22 4059 230 DRILL 5 SPINDLE TICO*M143 HCB 2B

    23 8438 240 DRILL I OSP TICO*M235 HCB 2B

    24 4032 250 SPYI 2 SPINDLE TICO*M135 HCB 2B

    25 9648 260 MILLING BEW SPM HCB 2B

    26 4077 270 BORER WAY ROUGH HCB 2B

    27 4463 280 HMT RD HCB 2B

    28 8560 290 DRILLING HMT RD HCB 2B

    29 4097 300 DRILL 3 SPINDLE 'ITO*M 149 HCB 2B

    30 10687 310 DRILL SPM HCB 2B

    31 4083 320 DRILL 4 SPINDLE HCB 2B

    32 9607 330 DRILLING SPM HCB 2B

    33 8257 340 DRILL 12 SPINDLE MMT*M200 HCB 2B

    34 4144 350 TAPPING 9 SPINDLE MMT HCB 2B

    35 4146 360 MMT 10 SPINDLE*M203 HCB 2B

    36 9093 380 OGPT SPM INDIA HCB 3B

    37 8584 390 MILLING & BROACH LML*M300 HCB 3B

    38 8863 400 SPM MILLING DUPLEX

    LML*M353 HCB 3B

    39 11417 410 LML PCN OPN HCB 3B

    40 4031 420 HB 800 PAL*73006 HCB 3B

    41 9663 430 CNC DRILLING HCB 3B

    42 8864 440 BORING FACING HMT*13465 HCB 3B

    43 4900 450 DRILL 2 SP 6 STN LML*M221 HCB 3B

    44 10033

      460 BFW ENNORE LML VML 1200

    VMC HCB 3B

    45 10418 480 BOLT TIGHTENING M/C HCB 3B

    4313 490 BORER 2 WAY LML*M221 HCB 3B

    47 10000 500 GROOVING HORZ*Y3562 HCB 3B

    48 9971 510 LML SPM HCB 3B

    49 4191 520 MILLING SPL VERT LML*M210 HCB 3B

    50 4464 530 BORER FINISH XLO*650382 HCB 4B

    51 9398 540 BORER FINISH LML HCB 4B

    52 9868 550 REAMING EMT*E511 HCB 4B

    53 4564 560 HONING GEHEING z 600-

    125*0009 HCB 4B

    54 4575 570 HORI DEBURR SPM HCB 4B

    55 9687 630 CAM BUSH PRESS HCB 4B

    56 9688 640 WELGE PLUG PRESS HCB 4B

    57 9690 650 WELGE PLUG PRESS HCB 4B

    58 9689 660 WELGE PLUG PRESS HCB 4B

    59 9621 680 OP TEST RIG HCB 4B

    60 4466 710 LINER PROJECTION HCB 4B

    3.0 MACHINING OPERATIONS

    3.1 DRILLING

    Drilling is process of making hole or enlarging a hole in an object by forcing a rotating tool called 'Drill'. The drill is generally called 'twist drill', since it has a sharp twisted edge formed around a cylindrical tool provided with a helical groove along its length to allow the cut material to escape through it. The sham edges of the conical surfaces ground at the lower end of the rotating twist drill cut the material by peeling it circularly layer by layer when forced against a work piece.

    The removed material chips get curled and escape through the helical grooves provided in the drill. A liquid coolant is generally used while drilling to remove the heat of friction and obtain a better finish for the hole.

    3.2 DRILLING MACHINE

    Drilling machine is one of the simplest, moderate and accurate machine tool used in production shop and tool room. It consists of a spindle which imparts rotary motion to the drilling tool, or mechanism for feeding the tool into the work, a table on which the work rests and a frame.

    Specifically, the various types of drilling machines are specified as follows:

  • Portable drilling machine

  • Sensitive and upright or bench drilling machines

  • Radial drilling machine

  • Multiple spindle drilling machines

  • Upright drilling machine Turret machine

  • Deep hole drilling machine.

    3.3 REAMING

    Reaming is the operation of finishing an existing hole very smoothly and accurately in size. A drill will not produce a hole having sufficiently good qualities of finish and accuracy for many purposes. Therefore, when a very accurate, smooth hole is required the hole is first drilled a little undersize. Then it is reamed to the correct size. The accuracy to be expected is within ± 0.005 mm.

    A reamer is a multi-tooth cutter which rotates and moves linearly into an already existing hole. The reamers are of following types:

  • Hand reamers

  • Chucking or machine reamers

  • Adjustable reamers

  • Expansion reamers

  • Taper reamers

  • Shell reamers

  • Carbide tipped reamers.

    3.4 BORING

    It is an operation of enlarging an existing hole. When a suitable size drill is not available, initially a hole is drilled to the nearest size and using a single point cutting tool made of HSS or carbide, the size of the hole is increased. By lowering the tool while it is continuously rotating, the size of the hole is increased to its entire depth. Boring machines are one of the largest of the machine tools and are able to machine work pieces weighing up to 180 kN.

    3.5 MILLING

    Milling is a process in which metal is removed by means of a  revolving cutter with many teeth, each tooth having a cutting edge which removes metal from a work piece. Milling machines are used to produce parts having flat as wells as curved shapes. Intricate shapes, which cannot be produced on the other machine tools, can be made on the milling machines. Generally, there are two types of milling process, namely:

  • Up milling (conventional milling) process

  • Down milling (climb milling) process.

    The milling machines are broadly classified as follows:

  • Column and knee type

  • Horizontal milling Machine

  • Vertical milling machine

  • Universal milling machine

  • Universal milling machine

  • Manufacturing or fixed bed type

  • Simplex milling machine

  • Duplex milling machine

  • Triplex milling machine

  • Planer type

  • Special type

  • Rotary table mill machine.

  • Drum milling machine

  • Planetary milling machine.

    3.6 COUNTERBORING

    It is an operation of enlarging a drilled hole particularly that IS for a specific length generally done to accommodate the socket head screws or grooved nuts or round head bolts. The counter boring forms a large sized recess or a shoulder to the existing hole. The speeds for counter boring must be two thirds of the drilling speed of the corresponding size of the chilled hole.

    3.7 HONING

    Honing is an abrasive Machining process that produces a precision surface on a metal work piece by scrubbing an abrasive stone against it along a controlled path. Honing is primarily used to improve the geometric form of a surface but may also improve the surface texture.

    Typical applications are the finishing of cylinders for internal combustion engines, air bearing spindles and gears. There are many types of hones, but all consist of one or more abrasive stones that are held under pressure against the surface they are working on.

    3.8. TAPPING       The tapping is a highly efficient threading process. This method offers productive and economical threading especially for smaller threads through reduced machine down time, higher  cutting speeds and long tool life.Forming taps and cutting taps come in different designs. The material, coating and geometry of the tap are very  important features to be considered for each tap style. A material or application may not be working effective for another material or application.

    4.0 MEASURING INSTRUMENTS

    4.1 Threaded plug gauge:

    This gauge is used to check whether the diameter of thread is within the given range or not.

    Method of use:

  • If the Go thread plug goes in to the threaded hole and the No Go does not, then the product is usually considered within the tolerance limits and acceptable.

  • The specifications state that the product can be acceptable if the No Go thread ring engages the end threads of the product being tested but should not thread over more than 3 (three) complete turns on the product.

  • Do not force the gage on t
    o the product and on thin walled parts, be especially aware that the gage may be more  easily forced into or over the product distorting the product.

    Result of inspection:

  • When thread is checked with Go thread plug, it did not go into the threaded hole fully indicating most of the M8 and M10 holes are partially tapped.

  • When it is checked with No Go thread plug, it did not make a round at all indicating the threads are produced in correct sizes.

  • So, the only problem is, the thread is not tapped to the full length of the hole.

    Note:

    The inspection has to be made only after properly cleaning the surface

    5.0 SCOPE OF THE PROJECT

    5.1 SCOPE

    In this project an attempt is made to reduce scrap and rework in tapping (LA 8547) and drilling operations (LA 4058 & LA 4032) of  H-series cylinder block in Machine shop-1.

    5.2 OBJECTIVES

    Tapping:

  • To reduce the scrap and rework produced by manual tap breakage.

  • To check whether the hole is tapped completely or not because it ultimately leads to manual tapping thereby increasing the manual tap breakage.

  • To check whether the holes entering the machine are cleaned (without burr) or not.

  • To check whether the coolant is flowing in correct direction at correct pressure.

  • To make the holes tapped completely by cleaning the holes before tapping and maintaining the correct coolant flow direction.

    Drilling:

  • To reduce the scrap and rework produced by drill bit breakage.

  • To check whether correct feed rate is used or not.

  • To check for correct spindle speed.

  • To check for correct coolant flow rate and  direction.

  • To analyze the drill bit material.

  • To check for correct bush size.

  • To check for correct frequency.

  • To check for vibrations in machine.

    LA 8547 – RH Tap

    LA 4032 – HF 7mm water hole

    LA 4058 – HF 4mm water hole

    LA 4191 – HF finish milling

    LA 8405 – FE Tap

    LA 4033 – HF angular 6.8mm water hole

    LA 9880 – FE /RE drill

    LA 4463 – Dipstick hole drill

    LA 4564 – Honing

    Project Planning:

    Gantt Chart: It is a tool used to plan the project ahead of time and helps to complete the project with in schedule. The Gantt chart has been attached as follows.

    6.0 Root Cause Validation:

    6.1 L 8547 – MULTI TAP ON RH PROBLEM

    PROBLEM:

    No proper tapping is provided for all the holes. The tap is either incomplete or it is not at all made.

    COLLECTING DETAILS ON LA 8547:

    Speed Clamping pressure Types of tap made

    300-340 rpm 40-50 Kg/sq.cm M8 × 1.25 and M10 ×1.5

    ON VISUAL MONITERING:

    POSITIVES:

  • Proper HSS tool with titanium coating is used

  • The torque of the CNC machine is good enough

  • Tools are replaced in regular intervals

  • There is no misalignment between the tap and the hole.

  • Feed rate is also fairly maintained.

    NEGATIVES:

  • Burr produced in the drilling operation is left unremoved

  • Chamfering is not properly made in all the holes.

  • Usage of float tapping reverts the tap back if experienced by any axial load.

    SORTING OUT THE REASONS:

    CHAMFERING IS NOT PROPER

    Chamfering for those holes on the RH side is made in LA 8551 using the sub land drill tool which simultaneously produces the hole and chamfers it.

    USAGE OF FLOAT TAPPING

    Float taping is used so that it prevents the tool from breakage. If there is any axial load experienced by the tool the spring takes it and reverts the tool back which leads to improper tapping.

    BURR NOT REMOVED

    If burr is not removed from the holes it may act as an obstruction to the tapping tool and result in improper tap. So, for all three reasons we need to know about the machine that drills these holes

    6.2 LA 8551- DRILLING ON RH SIDE

    PROBLEM

  • Coolant flow type

  • Chamfer provided by the sub land drill tool

    ON OBSERVATION

  • During drilling the coolant flow is not directed toward the hole, it just falls on the component which aids only cooling of the component which aids only cooling of which leaves the drilled holes with burr.

  • Good chamfer guides the tap properly into the hole. Improper end butting, tool wear leads to bad chamfer. So, due to this torque given my machine is not enough to overcome the increased resistance torque.

    Details of LA 8551

    Spindle speed Cutting feed

    6.8 DRILL 590-610 RPM 6.8 DRILL 170-180 mm/min

    EXPERIMENTATION:

    REGULAR PROCESS:

  • Usually the hole in the job is not cleaned after the drilling operation, it still had a lot of burr in the holes on visual observation.

  • On leaving the job directly to LA 8547 for tapping it is found that  certain holes are not tapped properly.

    ON CLEANING:

  • We manually cleaned all the drilled holes using the blower and passed it to LA 8547.

  • By cleaning the holes about 50% of the incomplete taps where complete for e.g., one of the M10 hole was always incomplete and the thread gauge would stop 5mm before the face, but on removing the burr and cleaning the hole we observed that the tap was much more complete with the thread gauge venturing completely into the hole.

    6.3 LA 4032 AND 4058 – DRILL ON HF

    PROBLEM:

    Frequent breakage of drill bit which significantly adds up in the no of  components to be reworked.

    ON OBSERVATION:

  • The Material used for the drill bit was HSS

  • The gap between the component and the bush was larger in LA 4032

  • The tool change frequency for the drill bit was inappropriate compared to the other similar machine

    Details of LA 4032

    Spindle speed Cutting feed

    810 RPM 100-110 mm/min

    Details of LA 4058

    Spindle speed Cutting feed

    610 RPM 65-80 mm/min

    6. BRAIN STORMING

    FOR LA 8547

    Sl.No IDEAS GENERATED

    1 Tap length less

    2 Tap wear

    3 Tap setting fault

    4 Presence of burr in the hole

    5 Clamping pressure less

    6 Insufficient coolant provided

    7 Not enough torque produced in machine

    8 Improper budding of job

    9 Chamfer less

    10 Improper shape of hole

    11 Power cut

    12 Usage of floating tap setup

    13 Absence of jig

    For LA 4058 and LA 4032

    Sl.NO IDEAS GENERATED

    1 Tool material

    2 Tool life

    3 Tool total length

    4 Tool flank length

    5 Tool shank length

    6 Spindle speed

    7 Feed rate

    8 Jig/bush design

    9 Proper coolant provided

    10 Proper removal of chips

    11 Clamping pressure

    12 Power cut

    13 Overheating of tool

    7. FISH BONE DIAGRAM FOR DRILLING:

    7.1 FISHBONE DIAGRAM FOR TAPPING:

    8. Root Cause Validation for LA 8547

    Sl.No Potential causes Verification Validation of the causes Action plan

    1 Tap length Measured using

    Vernier caliper No Tap length should be verified frequently

    2 Presence of burr in hole Visual Yes Should be removed by coolant or manually by using blowers

    3 Chamfer less Using thread gauge Yes Sub land drill

    4 Absence of jig Visual Yes Jig should be provided to guide the tapping tool

    5 Improper shape of hole Using gauge No The holes should be checked with gauge frequently.

    9. VALIDATION OF CAUSES FOR LA 4032 AND LA 4058

    Sl.No Potential causes Verification Validation of the causes Action plan

    1 Drill total length Measured using

    Vernier caliper Yes Total length of the drill bit should be made for the prescribed length by the machine builder.

    2 Improper bush design Visual Yes Should be removed by coolant or manually by using blowers

    3 Spindle speed Non-contact tachometer No Monitoring the spindle speed regularly

    4 Cutting feed Stopwatch No Monitoring the cutting feed regularly

    5 Improper cooling system Visual No Period
    ic check on air flow rate

    9. ROOT CAUSE CONSOLIDATION:

    TAPPING:

    9.1. CHAMPER IN THE HOLE

    The chamfer produced in the predrilled hole is not proper, so the tapping tool is not guided towards the hole properly.

    9.2 REMOVAL OF BURR

    The burr produced during the drilling operations is not completely removed because of the insufficient amount of force given to the coolant in the drilling operations which eventually acts as a disturbance during tapping process and results in partial tap.

    DRILLING:

    9.3. TOOL LIFE

    The tool life of the drilling machine is more when compared with other machines which leads to premature drill bit breakage and results in rework/scrap.

    9.4. BUSH DESIGN

    The bush design is in such a way that the gap between the block and the bush is large. more the gap, less is the support given to the drill bit and a small force acting on it may break the drill bit

    10. ACTION FOR ROOT CAUSE ELIMINATION

    OLD BUSH DESIGN:

    WHY WE CHANGED THE BUSH DESIGN?

    The new bush design is made based on the consideration of support to be given to the bush without disturbing the removal of chips during drilling operation.

    ADVANTAGES OF NEW BUSH:

  • It provides more support to the drill bit

  • Chips are removed easily without any disturbance

  • Tool breakage is reduced

  • Rework components are reduced

    The new bush design is given below.

    CHANGED BUSH DESIGN:

    11.FEASIBILITY STUDY

    For LA 4058 AND 4032

    Action plan Technical Economical Operational

    To change the flute length of the tool Yes No Yes

    To reduce the overhanging of the tool Yes No Yes

    To change the drill bit material Yes No Yes

    To provide coating for the drill bit Yes No Yes

    To increase the frequency of tool change span of drill bit Yes Yes Yes

    To change the bush design thereby reducing the gap between bush and the job Yes Yes Yes

    For LA 8547

    Action plan Technical Economical Operational

    To change the attachment of tapping setup frequently Yes No No

    To remove the burr in the hole before tapping operation Yes No Yes

    To manually clean the hole before tapping using blower Yes Yes No

    To provide proper coolant system in drilling machine to remove all the burr produced Yes No Yes

    To make the coolant flow in advance in tapping machine to remove the burr in hole No Yes Yes

    12. IMPLEMENTATION

    WHAT WHY WHERE HOW

    Change the bush design by increasing the length of the bush To increase the support given to the tool and to maintain proper removal of chips LA 4032 By machining a new bush for increased length and changing the old bush with the new one

    To decrease the frequency of tool change period from 240 to 100 Comparing with other similar operation machines the frequency of tool change period is inappropriate LA 4032 By requesting EHWA to change the tool for every 100 blocks

    To decrease the frequency of tool change period from 240 to 100 Comparing with other similar operation machines the frequency of tool change period is inappropriate LA 4058 By requesting EHWA to change the tool for every 100 blocks

    13. RECOMMENDATION

    WHAT WHY WHERE HOW

    To remove the burr in the drilled hole before tapping operation. The burr present in the hole during tapping causes disturbances to the tapping setup thereby reverting the tool back to its initial position without tapping the hole completely LA 8547 *To provide the coolant properly in drilling operation to remove the burr

    *To provide the coolant in advance in tapping machine to remove the burr before tapping operation starts

    14. PROJECT OUTCOMES

    For LA 4058

    Before Lean Implementation:

    NO OF COMPONENTS IN MONITERED NO OF COMPONENTS SENT FOR REWORK PERCENTAGE OF REWORK COMPONENTS

    4500 14 0.311

    After Lean Implementation:

    NO OF COMPONENTS MONITERED NO OF COMPONENTS SENT FOR REWORK PERCENTAGE OF REWORK COMPONENTS

    (%) % OF REWORK REDUCED

    (%)

    515

    0

    0

    100

    For LA 4032

    Before Implementation

    NO OF COMPONENTS MONITERED NO OF COMPONENTS SENT FOR REWORK PERCENTAGE OF REWORK COMPONENTS

    (%)

    4500

    20

    0.44

    After Implementation

    NO OF COMPONENTS MONITERED NO OF COMPONENTS SENT FOR REWORK PERCENTAGE OF REWORK COMPONENTS

    (%) % OF REWORK REDUCED

    (%)

    490

    1

    0.2

    54.54

    For LA 8547

    Without Cleaning with blower

    Component No M10 M8

    Fully tapped Nos Partially tapped Nos Fully tapped Nos Partially tapped Nos

    AZ 971 4 3 12 6

    AZ 966 3 4 11 7

    AZ 967 5 2 13 5

    AZ 969 3 4 13 5

    AZ 847 4 3 12 6

    AZ 845 2 5 15 3

    AZ 848 3 4 14 4

    AZ 854 5 2 13 5

    AZ 880 2 5 16 2

    AFTER CLEANING WITH BLOWER

    Component No M10 M8

    Fully tapped Nos Partially tapped Nos Fully tapped Nos Partially tapped Nos

    AZ 962 6 1 18 0

    AZ 963 5 2 18 0

    AZ 964 7 0 17 1

    AZ 965 6 1 18 0

    AZ 968 6 1 16 2

    AZ 950 5 2 17 1

    AZ 951 7 0 16 2

    AZ 953 6 1 18 0

    AZ 956 6 1 17 1

    TOTAL NO OF COMPONENTS TOTAL M8 HOLES FULLY TAPPED TOTAL M10 HOLES FULLY TAPPED

    9

    162 UNCLEANED CLEANED

    63 UNCLEANED CLEANED

    119 155 32 54

    15. BENEFITS

    For LA 4058

    For LA 4032

    15.1 COST ESTIMATION FOR A REWORK

    1.LA 4032

    Approx. working time – 30 mins/block Tool cost = Rs 1.8/block

    MAN ASSOCIATE   – Rs 215 / Hr.

    ASSISTANT   – Rs 42 /Hr.

    MACHINE DRILLING MACHINE – Rs 72/ Hr.

    SPARK MACHINE – Rs 60/Hr.

    TOTAL COST FOR A BLOCK = 389/2 + tool cost = Rs 196.3

    BEFORE IMPLEMENTATION:

    TOTAL NO OF REWORK COMPONENTS FOR 4500 BLOCKS -20

    TOTAL COST FOR 20 COMPONENTS = 20 X 196.3 = Rs 3926

    AFTER IMPLEMENTATION:

    TOTAL NO OF REWORK COMPONENTS FOR 4500 BLOCKS – 9

    TOTAL COST FOR 16 COMPONENTS = 9 X 196.3 = Rs 1766.7

    INVENTORY COST

    Inventory cost for one block = Rs 12,000

    BEFORE IMPLEMENTATION:

    TOTAL NO OF REWORK COMPONENTS FOR 4500 BLOCKS -20

    TOTAL INVENTORY COST FOR 16 COMPONENTS = 20 X 12000= Rs 2,40,000

    AFTER IMPLEMENTATION:

    TOTAL NO OF REWORK COMPONENTS FOR 4500 BLOCKS – 9

    TOTAL INVENTORY COST FOR 16 COMPONENTS = 9 X 12000 = Rs 1,08,000

    2.LA 4058

    Approx. working time – 30 mins/block Tool cost = Rs 1.8/block

    MAN ASSOCIATE   – Rs 215 / Hr.

    ASSISTANT   – Rs 42 /Hr.

    MACHINE DRILLING MACHINE – Rs 72/ Hr.

    SPARK MACHINE – Rs 60/Hr.

    TOTAL COST FOR A BLOCK = 389/2 + tool cost = Rs 196.3

    BEFORE IMPLEMENTATION:

    TOTAL NO OF REWORK COMPONENTS FOR 4500 BLOCKS -14

    TOTAL COST FOR 20 COMPONENTS = 14 X 196.3 = Rs 2748.2

    AFTER IMPLEMENTATION:

    TOTAL NO OF REWORK COMPONENTS FOR 4500 COMPONENTS – 0

    TOTAL COST FOR 16 COMPONENTS = Rs 0

    INVENTORY COST

    Inventory cost for one block = Rs 12,000

    BEFORE IMPLEMENTATION:

    TOTAL NO OF REWORK COMPONENTS FOR 4500 COMPONENTS -14

    TOTAL INVENTORY COST FOR 16 COMPONENTS = 14 X 12000 = Rs 1,68,000

    AFTER IMPLEMENTATION:

    TOTAL NO OF REWORK COMPONENTS FOR 4500 COMPONENTS – 0

    TOTAL INVENTORY COST FOR 16 COMPONENTS = 0 X 12000 = Rs 0

    Break Even Analysis:

    BEP = 32 Units.

    16. LIMITATIONS

  • The tool change frequency should be maintained

  • The bush design should be monitored for any fouling and the bush design should not be changed if there is any breakage.

  • Proper removal of burr should be checked before passing the block to the tapping machine.

  • The no of blocks machined should be monitored and once the tool change period reaches, the tool should be changed without any delay.

    17. SCOPE FOR FURTHER IMPROVEMENT

    For LA 4058 and LA 4032

    17.1 CHANGING THE TOOL MATERIAL OR PROVIDING THE  COATING TO THE TOOL

    By providing coating or by changing the tool material the life of the drill
    bit is increased thereby the tool breakage and the rework components will be reduced

    REFERENCE: Material science and engineering by William D Callister

    17.2 BY REDUCING THE FLUTE AND TOOL LENGTH OF THE TOOL

    By reducing the flute or the total length of the tool, the overhung distance of the tool is reduced and the forces acting on the tool is minimized, and the drill breakage is reduced.

    17.3 PROPER COOLING SYSTEM SHOULD BE PROVIDED

    Now air is used as a coolant for these machines, usage of coolant removes burr completely and also cools the drill bit which decreases the risk of drill breakage.

    REFERENCE: Contemporary drill design by Kenneth M Snoeck

    18.LEARNING

  • By completing this project, we gained industrial exposure and enhanced our practical exposure with CNC machines and all the  machining processes.

  • The problem-solving methodology helped us analysis the industrial problem and helped us solve it more efficiently.

  • We learned how a machine shop will be organized and problems faced by the executives in handling the bays of the shop.

  • The brainstorming sessions helped us think out of the box and gave out various reasons for the problem.

  • We learned the work nature of the BE graduates and what the company expects from them.

  • We learned about each and every machining processes like milling, drilling, tapping, reaming, honing, boring, etc., in detail.

  • We learned how to initiate and progress through the various stages of industrial projects.

  • We learned the vital role played by safety in an industry and its importance.

    19.CONCLUSION

    This project is started because of more number rework/scrap components produced in drilling (LA 4032 and LA 4058) and tapping (LA 8547)  operations on H-Series cylinder block at Machine Shop – I. For increasing the productivity of the shop, the following implementations and recommendations are given and successfully tested.

    IMPLEMENTIONS:

  • The bush design of LA 4032 has been changed to reduce the gap between the block and the bush

  • The tool change frequency of LA 4032 and LA 4058 has been increased.

    RECOMMENDATION:

    The burr produced while drilling in RH face should be removed either by coolant or by blowers to reduce the partial tapping problem thereby reducing the tap breakage during manual tapping process.

    20. BIBILIOGRAPHY

  • Material science and engineering by William D Callister

  • Contemporary drill design by Kenneth M Snoeck

  • Manufacturing Engineering and Technology by Serope kalpakjiyan and Steven R Schmid

  • About this essay:

    If you use part of this page in your own work, you need to provide a citation, as follows:

    Essay Sauce, Increasing The Productivity By Reducing The Scrap And Rework Using Lean Manufacturing. Available from:<https://www.essaysauce.com/engineering-essays/2018-11-8-1541711601/> [Accessed 13-04-26].

    These Engineering essays have been submitted to us by students in order to help you with your studies.

    * This essay may have been previously published on EssaySauce.com and/or Essay.uk.com at an earlier date than indicated.