Home > Sample essays > How Guilt and Wrong Judgment Contributes to the Crime in The Tell Tale Heart

Essay: How Guilt and Wrong Judgment Contributes to the Crime in The Tell Tale Heart

Essay details and download:

  • Subject area(s): Sample essays
  • Reading time: 6 minutes
  • Price: Free download
  • Published: 1 April 2019*
  • Last Modified: 23 July 2024
  • File format: Text
  • Words: 1,705 (approx)
  • Number of pages: 7 (approx)

Text preview of this essay:

This page of the essay has 1,705 words.



The sequence of events in “The Tell-Tale Heart” involve a man who thirst to assassinate another man but does not wish to be arrested and disciplined according to the law. Due to this, we have to pretend that he plans to undertake a perfect crime although the storyteller does not speak a lot about him until when the act happens and decides to hide the dead body under the floor panel. The narrator indicates how he spends time observing the moves of the old man and he does every night, and this gives him detail which leads to the actual murder. Moreover, the narrator wants to get by with murder as a way of fulfilling his desire. As a reader, we tend to think he is reliant on this older man, and he may gain something once he kills him. The victim could not be his father but he can be the uncle of the narrator, and this gives the narrator a position to inherit the household and some money which this old man owned (Poe p. 8). Furthermore, the intention why the narrator murders the old man could not be as a result of the old man’s pale blue eye and anything to do with his property. This is approximately a perfect-crime narration in which the perpetrator nearly gets with it without for one fault. From this stories, the reader understands perpetrator point of view, and this causes a reader to identify some traits outlined. Once the narrator breaks and gives room for confession, the reader also participates in sharing the feeling of being uncovered and seized. According to the act of murder, the narrator is seen as insane, and it can be observed a certain force motivates him to a point of killing the old man. Following the killing, the narrator dispute against his madness, yet he later disproves that argument when he admits continuing to be haunted by the former innocent man’s heartbeat, and this drives him to further acts of insanity to a point of dismembering the old man and hiding him beneath the floorboards. In the description, the narrator outlines his animosity towards the former man although there is no real reason for this hatred. According to the narrator, the old man’s eye knows his inner heart and as a result, of this, he fears and hence eliminates him. The rising action and climax are evidenced when the narrator kills the old man and buries him beneath the floorboards believing that nothing about him will be exposed to the old man. Moreover, the falling action happens when the narrator discloses to the police of his wrongdoing.

Themes in Edgar Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart.”

The first topic is the effect of guilt or conscience. The being inner spirit which is the heart cannot withstand the weight of condemnation especially when murder is involved. The guilt must be confessed in one way to ensure someone is not consumed by his or her conscience. In the story, the storyteller eliminates the aged man since he had a pale blue eyes but later a guilt feeling is developed. In the basis, the storyteller seems to have confidence and reluctant for what he has done and evaluates himself as a clever person to have gotten away with the murder. Despite police arriving he display a calm nature which shows nothing is wrong at the moment, and even he directs them into the room of the aged man. "Because of the excitement of my certainty, I drew seats where the police were in the room and wished for them to stay and rest from their debility, while I, in the wild braveness of my complete happiness, set my particular chair around the very spot underneath where the cadaver of the casualty rested comfortably. (p. 6)" The guilt conscience develops and bothers him to a point where he begins to think how the heart of the old man is beating. “Be that as it may, I felt myself been uncomfortable because of their presence and wished them gone. My head throbbed, and I developed a ringing tone in my ears which triggered myself because of the action I did… (p. 6)” Mental instability was growing, and that was why the narrator could hear ringing in his ears representing his conscience. It becomes apparent that the storyteller start losing focus from his mind and this clearly indicated to the police that narrator could be the prime suspect.

As argued by Poe, love and Hate are another themes that are clearly discussed. It is seen how the narrator discloses his genuine care and love for the old man whom he later violently assassins and separates his body parts (p. 10). Abnormality is displayed by the narrator when he attempts to disconnect the person of the aged man whom he claims he truly loves from the old man’s pale blue evil eye and this alerts hatred in the storyteller. Because of the delusional separation, the narrator remains unconscious of the paradox of claiming to have loved his victim. Furthermore, there is a strange hatred between the narrator and the old man, and this is evidenced by the old man’s eye which is the core reason for the hatred. The storyteller tends to think there is more hidden information which disclosed his inner heart and, therefore, needs to eliminate the old man. Although narrator sympathizes when the old man lets out a groan, a feeling like chuckling arise.

Do not judge people by the outer cover. The narrator decided the old man wrongly because of his pale blue eye, and this made him make a horrible kind of crime which made him be jailed (Poe p. 14). He was also making fun of him and mocking him. Because of wrong judgment, the narrator decides to kill the old man who is innocent, and this created a guilt feeling in the life of the narrator. Moreover, when the narrator welcomes the police officers when they arrive, the police themselves tend to think the narrator is innocent. They make the wrong judgment because of the warm welcome from the murderer. The police officers continue to accept the narrator's story until the time his guilt conscience overtakes him to a point where he disclosed all the required information to the police. The police officers could not have realized the prime suspect since they saw narrator as someone who was upright and genuine at the beginning of the investigation. The guilt conscience made the narrator confess to killing the old man, and this brought the actual and justice in fulfillment although the life of the old man was lost through death.

Analysis

Poe uses his words fiscally as a part of the "Obvious Heart" it is one of his most diminutive stories and gives an examination of loathsomeness and mental rot. Poe strips the story of excess purpose of enthusiasm as a component to raise the professional killer's obsession with specific and unadorned components: the matured man's eye, the beat, and his particular issue to sensible soundness. Poe's fiscal style and guided vernacular therefore upgrade toward the record quality substance, and this relationship of plan and substance truly exemplifies precariousness. To be sure, as in Poe himself, like the pounding heart, is complicit in the plot to get the storyteller in his vindictive diversion.

As a study in suspicion, this story illuminates the scholarly differences that add to a fatal profile. For example, the storyteller yields, in the most extreme sentence, to being terrifyingly uneasy, yet he cannot get a handle on why he should be thought upset. He verbalizes his self-protection against franticness regarding high tactile limit. The storyteller of "The Tell-Tale Heart" sees his extreme touchiness as verification of his logical soundness, not a side effect of frenzy. This unique learning empowers the storyteller to tell this story in an exact and finish way, and he utilizes the elaborate apparatuses of portrayal for the reasons of his rational soundness supplication (Poe, p. 17). Notwithstanding, what makes this storyteller distraught and most dissimilar to Poe is that he neglects to understand the coupling of account shape and substance. He aces exact structure, yet he unwittingly lays out a story of homicide that sells out the franticness he needs to deny.

Another disagreement integral to the story includes the pressure between the storyteller's abilities for adoration and scorn. Poe investigates here a mysterious riddle that individuals at times hurt those whom they adore or require in their lives. Poe's storyteller cherishes the old man. He is not ravenous for the old man's riches, nor vindictive as a result of any slight. The storyteller in this way disposes of thought processes that may ordinarily rouse such a brutal homicide. As he proclaims his specific balanced soundness, the storyteller concentrates on the old man's vulture-eye. He diminishes the old man to the light blue of his eye in a savage way. He needs to discrete the man from his "Hostile stare" so he can spare the man the heaviness of accuse that he credits to the eye itself (Poe p. 23). The storyteller fails to see that the eye is the "I" of the old man, a novel bit of his identity that can't be disengaged as the storyteller absurdly imagines.

As per Poe, the homicide of the old man speaks to the extent to which the storyteller disconnects the old man's character from his physical eye, (p. 30). The storyteller sees the eye as completely separate from the man, and as needs be, he is fit for slaughtering him while keeping up that he loves him. The storyteller's longing to murder the man's eye moves his crime; be that as it may, the storyteller does not perceive this show will end the man's life. By debilitating his loss, the storyteller further prevents the old man from securing his humankind. The storyteller confirms his start of the old man's eye as divided from the man by finish and changing him into such an assortment of parts. That method double-crosses him when his cerebrum imagines distinctive parts of the old man's body clashing with him.

About this essay:

If you use part of this page in your own work, you need to provide a citation, as follows:

Essay Sauce, How Guilt and Wrong Judgment Contributes to the Crime in The Tell Tale Heart. Available from:<https://www.essaysauce.com/sample-essays/2016-3-11-1457654402/> [Accessed 16-04-26].

These Sample essays have been submitted to us by students in order to help you with your studies.

* This essay may have been previously published on EssaySauce.com and/or Essay.uk.com at an earlier date than indicated.